The Prisoners Who Named the Shadows
Plato—the Allegory of the Cave
| A |
thens. 375 BC. A story is being told in the dark. The storyteller is Socrates, the Athenian who taught by asking questions. His listener is Glaucon, the older brother of Plato. Picture a cave, Socrates says. Deep underground. People have lived down there since birth. |
Plato (about 428–348 BC) later wrote the scene down, in his book the Republic. He was Socrates’s student. He went on to found the Academy in Athens, the first university in the West.
Now, the cave itself. These people are chained. Their legs and necks are fixed in place. They can only face one blank wall.
Behind them burns a fire. Between the fire and the prisoners runs a low walkway. Along it, unseen people carry objects… statues, tools, little figures of animals.
The fire throws the shadows of those objects onto the wall the prisoners face. And shadows are all these prisoners have ever seen.
So they take the shadows for the whole world. They give the shadows names. Whoever guesses which shadow comes next is honoured as wise. In 1604, a Dutch engraver named Jan Saenredam tried to picture the entire scene.
|
| Jan Saenredam, ‘Antrum Platonicum’ (The Cave of Plato), 1604, after Cornelis van Haarlem. |
Look at the wall on the left. Prisoners sit huddled, staring at shapes cast in front of them. Behind them, a low screen. On it, small figures throw their shadows across the stone. Far to the right, a bright mouth opens onto the daylight world… where almost no one is looking.
Now free one prisoner, Socrates says. He turns around. The fire hurts his eyes at once. The climb toward the mouth of the cave is steep, and every step is painful.
Outside, the sun blinds him. Slowly, though, his eyes adjust. He sees shadows first, then reflections in water, then real things standing in the light. At last he can look up at the sun itself.
The sun, Socrates explains, stands for the highest truth of all. He calls it the Form of the Good. The climb out of the cave is what learning really is.
Then the freed man goes back down to tell the others. His eyes no longer fit the dark. He fumbles, and stumbles over shadows he once read with ease.
The others laugh. The climb ruined his sight, they say. Better to stay put. And if he tried to drag them out toward the light? They would kill him.
Plato knew that danger first-hand. His own teacher, Socrates, had been put to death by Athens in 399 BC, for asking too many hard questions. The killing in the cave is partly about him.
I first read this on a train, in my thirties, understanding almost none of the philosophy books I owned. And then this simple picture landed. I had spent years mistaking a lit screen for the world. Most of us have.
That is why the cave never dies. It gave us a word we still use: enlightenment, the walk from dark into light. It shaped René Descartes, the French philosopher who in 1641 doubted his own senses. It shaped our films too. When Neo, the hero of the 1999 film The Matrix, learns his whole world is a fake… that is the cave, told again.
So here is the useful question. It is the one the whole allegory is built to leave you with.
What shadows are you naming today?
|
