The comedy that triumphed on Valentine’s night, and the playwright whose name was erased from it ten weeks later… plus three things worth knowing today.

Good morning.

Today, a snowy Valentine’s night in London, 1895… a playwright at the peak of his fame, and the ten weeks that ended it.

Let’s begin.

   

The Night Wilde Refused to Bow

Oscar Wilde—“The Importance of Being Earnest”

L ondon. 14 February, 1895. Snow was falling outside the St. James’s Theatre. Inside, the best-dressed crowd in London settled into their seats. They had come to see a new comedy by the most talked-about writer in England.

Oscar Wilde (1854–1900) was an Irish poet, novelist, and playwright, living in London. By 1895 he had already written three hit plays in three years. The Importance of Being Earnest was meant to be his biggest yet, a farce about two men who invent fake identities to escape their responsibilities.

The gamble paid off instantly. Allan Aynesworth, who played the role of Algernon, later called it the finest opening night of his fifty-three years on stage. The audience rose in their seats and cheered and cheered again.

This is Wilde thirteen years earlier, already the most photographed writer of his generation.

Oscar Wilde, photographed by Napoleon Sarony, 1882
Napoleon Sarony, “Oscar Wilde,” 1882. Library of Congress, Washington, D.C.

Napoleon Sarony (1821–1896) ran the most famous celebrity photo studio in New York. He shot this during Wilde’s 1882 lecture tour of America, styling him as a velvet-clad aesthete before Wilde had written a single play. Sarony later sued a lithography company for copying this exact photograph without paying him, and won, in a case that decided, for the first time in American law, that a photograph could be copyrighted at all.

Back to opening night. In the audience that Valentine’s evening sat a man Wilde badly wanted kept out: the Marquess of Queensberry (1844–1900), father of Wilde’s companion Lord Alfred Douglas. Queensberry planned to disrupt the show with a bouquet of rotten vegetables. Wilde got wind of it, had Queensberry’s ticket cancelled, and posted police at every door. Furious, the Marquess left his bouquet at the stage door instead.

I first saw this play as a teenager, laughing hardest at Lady Bracknell’s two-word reaction to a baby found in a handbag: “A handbag?” I had no idea, watching it, that the man who wrote those lines would be in a prison cell within the year.

Queensberry kept pushing. A card he left at Wilde’s club accused him, in writing, of a crime under Victorian law. Wilde sued him for libel. The case collapsed within days, and the evidence gathered for Wilde’s defense was handed straight to the police. He was arrested for gross indecency on 5 April, seven weeks after his triumphant opening night.

The theater tried to save the production without saving its author. Starting 6 April, Wilde’s name was removed, with no announcement, from the programme and the posters outside. It made no difference. The play closed on 8 May, after eighty-three performances, the same week Wilde’s own trial resumed.

Wilde served two years of hard labor. In prison, he wrote a long, unsparing letter that was later published as De Profundis. He died in Paris in 1900, at forty-six, with barely any money left. The Importance of Being Earnest has never once left the stage since.

One bouquet of rotten vegetables… delivered to a stage door instead of a stage.

Wilde dodged that insult on opening night. The one that followed, he could not.

   

Three Things Worth Knowing

I Art The Wrong Yellow Book

When police arrested Wilde, newspapers reported he was carrying a copy of The Yellow Book, a daring literary magazine art-directed by the illustrator Aubrey Beardsley (1872–1898). Beardsley had drawn Wilde’s Salome and knew him socially, but had actually kept Wilde’s writing out of the magazine. That didn’t matter. Angry crowds smashed the windows of its publisher, and Beardsley lost his job within days, for a book historians now think probably wasn’t even the one in Wilde’s hand.

II Philosophy Art for Art’s Sake

At Oxford, Wilde studied under Walter Pater (1839–1894), an unassuming, precise don whose 1873 book on the Renaissance argued that beauty needed no moral excuse. Art didn’t have to teach a lesson. It just had to be beautiful. Wilde carried that idea into everything he wrote, including a farce with, by his own admission, almost nothing serious to say.

III Architecture The Theater That Vanished

The St. James’s Theatre, where Wilde’s play premiered, stood on King Street in London from 1835 until 1957, when a property developer won permission to knock it down for offices. Laurence Olivier and Vivien Leigh, who had once run the theater themselves, led marches and lobbied the House of Lords to save it. They lost. A row of carved stone faces from the old balcony, including Wilde’s, still hangs in a narrow alley behind the office block that replaced it.

   

Connoisseur’s Diary

Worth Seeing This Week

The West End revival that closed in January is now streaming. The National Theatre’s acclaimed 2024 staging, directed by Max Webster, starred Sharon D Clarke as Lady Bracknell and Ncuti Gatwa as Algernon, and it is exactly as joyfully over-the-top as Wilde would have wanted.

Where: streaming worldwide on National Theatre at Home.  Price: rent individual titles from around £9.99, or subscribe monthly from about £9.99, with annual plans running roughly £99.98 for twelve months.  Insider tip: a subscription unlocks the back catalogue too, including several other Wilde-era revivals.  Watch at ntathome.com →

Worth Reading

The Importance of Being Earnest and Other Plays The Importance of Being Earnest and Other Plays — Oscar Wilde (2001). All four of Wilde’s society comedies in one volume, with the full, uncut fourth act restored.
Oscar Wilde Oscar Wilde — Richard Ellmann (1988). The Pulitzer Prize–winning biography, and still the fullest account of Wilde’s rise and fall.
De Profundis and Other Prison Writings De Profundis and Other Prison Writings — Oscar Wilde, ed. Colm Tóibín (2013). The long letter Wilde wrote from his prison cell, along with “The Ballad of Reading Gaol.”

Test Your Knowledge

1What did the Marquess of Queensberry plan to disrupt opening night with, before Wilde had him stopped?

A bouquet of rotten vegetables
A written protest read aloud from his seat
A rival actor hired to heckle from the gallery

Answer: A bouquet of rotten vegetables. Blocked from entering, Queensberry left it at the stage door instead, still furious.

2Whose career was wrecked when newspapers wrongly linked him to the book in Wilde’s arms at his arrest?

Aubrey Beardsley, illustrator of “The Yellow Book”
Walter Pater, Wilde’s Oxford tutor
George Alexander, the theater’s manager

Answer: Aubrey Beardsley. He was fired within days, for a magazine most historians now doubt Wilde was actually carrying.

3Who led the failed campaign to save the St. James’s Theatre from demolition in 1957?

Laurence Olivier and Vivien Leigh
Winston Churchill and his cabinet
Oscar Wilde’s grandson

Answer: Laurence Olivier and Vivien Leigh. They had once run the theater themselves; Leigh even interrupted the House of Lords to protest, without success.

If the links above don’t respond in your email app, just reply with your answers—I’ll write back.

   

That’s all for today.

Tomorrow, a poem still in the public domain… and the reason that matters for what we can print.

In good taste,

Charles T. Mayfair

Editor, Connoisseur Daily

P.S. Renting the National Theatre’s Earnest for one evening is nearly always cheaper than a monthly subscription… save the subscription for when three or four titles catch your eye at once.