A waterfall in Switzerland, thousands of angry readers, and a hat nobody wrote…

Good morning.

Today, a waterfall in the Swiss Alps… and the author who threw his most famous creation over the edge.

Let’s begin.

  ◆  

The Author Who Killed His Hero

Arthur Conan Doyle—Sherlock Holmes

S outhsea, England. 1886. A young doctor sits in his consulting room, waiting for patients who rarely come. To fill the hours, he writes.

His name is Arthur Conan Doyle. He is 27, and he has invented a detective who solves crimes by noticing what everyone else misses: a tan line, a worn sleeve, a speck of mud on a boot.

For the method, he drew on one of his old teachers at Edinburgh, the surgeon Joseph Bell, who could glance at a patient and guess his job and recent travels.

The first Sherlock Holmes story, A Study in Scarlet, appeared in a Christmas annual in 1887. Doyle sold the whole copyright for £25. Almost nobody noticed.

Then, in July 1891, a new monthly magazine called The Strand began printing short Holmes adventures, one complete story per issue, with drawings by the illustrator Sidney Paget. Within months, Holmes was the most famous detective in the world, and Doyle could name his price.

He was not pleased. Doyle wanted to be remembered for his serious historical novels, and the detective was eating all his time. Before the year was out, he wrote to his mother with a plan.

“I think of slaying Holmes… and winding him up for good and all. He takes my mind from better things.”

Arthur Conan Doyle, letter to his mother, 1891

In 1893, on holiday in Switzerland, Doyle visited the Reichenbach Falls, a thundering cascade above the village of Meiringen. Doyle knew he had found his scene.

In December 1893, readers opened The Strand and found this.

  ◆  

Elon Musk’s One Stock Retirement Plan

Sometimes you come across an opportunity so explosive…

That it has the potential to turn a small stake…

Into a six figure and in some rare cases even a seven-figure nest egg…

Like it happened when I picked Nvidia in 2016.

It jumped high enough to turn $5,000 into an entire retirement nest egg of $1,895,000.

And while I can’t guarantee you’ll become a millionaire...

I think this little-known AI stock is one of those opportunities…

Which is why I call it “Elon Musk’s One Stock Retirement Plan.”

Now, if this idea of retiring with a single stock sounds crazy to you…

You should know that some of the best investors in the world believe that the idea of diversification is a little overrated.

Stanley Druckenmiller said…

“You don’t get rich by diversifying into 50 mediocre assets. You get rich by finding two or three asymmetric home runs.”

I believe this stock is an asymmetric home run.

Or listen to legendary investor Peter Lynch. He said…

“I would own one stock if I can find one great stock.”

Even Warren Buffett said…

“Diversification is protection against ignorance. It makes little sense if you know what you are doing.”

Click here now and I’ll show you why I believe this stock might be the only one you need to retire.

P.S. If I could buy only one stock, this would be it… it might just be the perfect tech stock.

It’s a leader in an AI breakthrough that’s protected by 150 patents…

It’s a small company, unknown to most people… still in the initial phase of exponential growth…

Plus, it has a near term catalyst that could send shares skyrocketing… starting November 11.

  ◆  
Sidney Paget, The Death of Sherlock Holmes, 1893
Sidney Paget, “The Death of Sherlock Holmes,” illustration for “The Final Problem,” The Strand Magazine, December 1893. Public domain.

Look at the edge of the path. Holmes and his great enemy, the criminal mastermind Professor Moriarty, grapple at the very lip of the falls. Spray rises from below. One more step, and both men will go over.

In the story, that is exactly what seems to happen. Dr. Watson returns to find only Holmes’s alpine stick, a farewell note and two sets of footprints leading to the edge, and none coming back.

Doyle’s private notebook for that year contains a blunt entry: “Killed Holmes.”

The public was furious. The Strand reportedly lost around 20,000 subscribers, a serious blow for a magazine built on its star. Angry letters poured in, and one reader is said to have begun hers with two words: “You brute!”

Doyle did not budge. He wrote other books, served as a volunteer doctor in the Boer War in South Africa, and was knighted in 1902. For eight years, Holmes stayed dead.

Then a friend, the journalist Bertram Fletcher Robinson, told him a legend from Dartmoor in Devon about a spectral hound that haunted an old family. Doyle saw a perfect case for a perfect detective. But he did not resurrect Holmes. He simply set the new story before the fatal day at the falls.

The Hound of the Baskervilles ran in The Strand from 1901 to 1902, with Sidney Paget once again providing the pictures, at Doyle’s own request. Readers queued for each new issue.

This is how Paget showed the detective they had missed.

Sherlock Holmes, drawn by Sidney Paget
Sherlock Holmes, drawn by Sidney Paget for The Strand Magazine. Public domain.

Doyle finally gave in, in 1903. In “The Adventure of the Empty House,” Holmes walks back into Watson’s life, explaining that he had never gone over the falls at all. He had used a Japanese wrestling trick to throw Moriarty into the abyss, then hidden for three years.

In other words, the most famous death in detective fiction turned out to be the first great fake-out.

Doyle kept writing Holmes stories until 1927: four novels and 56 short stories in all. He died in 1930, still a little annoyed that the detective had outshone everything else he wrote.

Arthur Conan Doyle in 1914
Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, photographed by Walter Benington, 1914. Public domain.

I read “The Final Problem” as a boy, on a rainy afternoon, already knowing that Holmes would return. It made no difference. When Watson found the note at the falls, I put the book down and stared out of the window for a long time. That is what Doyle could do, even to a reader who knew the ending.

For the full story of Reichenbach, including the Swiss hotel where Doyle stayed, start here: The Final Problem →

Doyle wanted to be free of his detective. He threw him off a cliff… and the readers threw him straight back.

  ◆  

Three Things Worth Knowing

I Theater The Pipe and the Phrase

Much of Holmes’s look came from the stage, not the page. The American actor William Gillette played him from 1899, more than 1,300 times over the next three decades. Gillette helped popularise the curved pipe, and his play gave audiences a line very close to “Elementary, my dear Watson,” which Doyle himself never wrote. The image in your head is part Doyle, part Paget, part Gillette.

II Medicine The Real Sherlock

Joseph Bell (1837–1911) taught surgery at the University of Edinburgh, where the young Doyle worked as his clerk. Bell taught students to observe a patient’s hands, posture, accent and clothes before saying a word. Doyle openly named him as the model for Holmes, and Bell enjoyed the fame, though he insisted that Doyle himself had the detective’s gifts.

III History The Cottingley Fairies

The creator of the most rational detective in fiction was also a passionate believer in spiritualism. In 1920 Doyle published, in The Strand itself, photographs taken by two young cousins in Cottingley, Yorkshire, that appeared to show fairies dancing in a garden. He believed they were genuine. In 1983, the cousins, by then elderly, admitted that the fairies had been paper cut-outs held up with hatpins.

  ◆  

Curious & Controversial

◆ Did 20,000 readers really cancel their subscriptions? The figure is repeated everywhere and usually traced to the magazine’s own later recollections. It is plausible, but hard to verify precisely.
◆ Did young men in London wear black armbands in mourning for Holmes? It is one of the most famous stories about him, and almost certainly a legend. No contemporary evidence has been found.
◆ Holmes never says “Elementary, my dear Watson” in any of Doyle’s stories. And the deerstalker hat never appears in the text either. Sidney Paget drew it, and the world adopted it.
◆ How much credit does Bertram Fletcher Robinson deserve for The Hound of the Baskervilles? Doyle acknowledged him in the first edition. Some enthusiasts have argued he did far more, but most scholars treat that as unproven.
  ◆  

Connoisseur’s Diary

Worth Seeing This Week

The Sherlock Holmes Museum on Baker Street recreates the famous rooms at 221B, with Victorian furniture, Holmes’s chemistry set and scenes from the stories. It is gloriously theatrical, and a lot of fun.

Where: Sherlock Holmes Museum, 221b Baker Street, London NW1 6XE, near Baker Street tube station. Open daily, 9.30 a.m.–6 p.m.; last entry 5.30 p.m.  Tickets: from £19 for adults, £17 concessions, £14 for children aged 6–15; under-6s free.  Insider tip: Buy your ticket in the gift shop before you join the queue. And look closely at the door: the famous 221B actually sits between numbers 237 and 241.  Visit sherlock-holmes.co.uk →

Worth Reading

The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes — Arthur Conan Doyle (1894). The collection that ends with “The Final Problem.” It is in the public domain, so you can read it free tonight; the last story takes about forty minutes.

Explore Further

Read: The Final Problem →, the story, its publication and the reaction to Holmes’s death.

Tonight’s Quiz

1. Where did Doyle send Holmes to his apparent death in 1893?

A) The cliffs of Dover

B) The Reichenbach Falls

C) Lake Geneva

D) The Thames

Answer: B. Holmes and Moriarty seemed to go over the falls above Meiringen, in Switzerland, in “The Final Problem.”

2. Who first gave Holmes his famous deerstalker hat?

A) Arthur Conan Doyle

B) William Gillette

C) Sidney Paget

D) Joseph Bell

Answer: C. The hat never appears in the text; Paget drew it for The Strand.

3. What were the Cottingley Fairies, which Doyle believed were real?

A) Paper cut-outs held up with hatpins

B) Painted glass slides

C) Wax figures

D) Reflections on a pond

Answer: A. The two cousins who took the photographs admitted the trick in 1983.

If the links above don’t respond in your email app, just reply with your answers—I’ll write back.

  ◆  

Doyle tried to kill his creation and failed. Holmes outlived his author, his illustrator and every actor who played him. Some characters, once released, belong to the readers.

Tomorrow, the philosopher hired to teach a 13-year-old prince… who grew up to become Alexander the Great.

In good taste,
Charles T. Mayfair

Editor, Connoisseur Daily

P.S. If you have never read Holmes, start with “A Scandal in Bohemia,” the first Strand story. It is short, funny, and introduces Irene Adler, the one person who ever outwitted him.